From a series of lectures of HG Ravindra Svarupa Dasa (2015)

Part 01a

Summary

This is a recording of a lecture on the “cure of souls” in Vaishnava communities, particularly in the context of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON). The lecture examines the work of Anton T. Boisen, a Christian minister who underwent a spiritual crisis and subsequently developed the field of clinical pastoral education. Boisen’s insights into spiritual crisis and the laws of spiritual life are presented as potentially relevant to ISCKON’s own struggles with issues of personal failure, authority, and the process of socialization within the movement. The speaker encourages attendees to consider Boisen’s work as a tool for understanding and navigating these challenges within their own lives and within the larger ISCKON community.

What are the key differences between the traditional Vaishnava approach to spiritual advancement and Anton T. Boisen’s views on spiritual crisis and healing?

Vaishnava and Boisenian Approaches to Spiritual Advancement
The speaker discuss the traditional Vaishnava approach to spiritual advancement and Anton T. Boisen’s perspective on spiritual crisis and healing but do not directly compare the two. However, based on the information provided, here are some potential key differences:
●
Sense of Failure and Idealism: Boisen emphasizes the significance of a “sense of personal failure” in triggering spiritual crises, particularly within groups adhering to “very high ideals.” He posits that navigating this sense of failure, either constructively or destructively, shapes spiritual development. The Vaishnava tradition, as reflected in the Bhagavad Gita verses cited, similarly highlights the importance of being “rightly situated in your determination” for spiritual progress. While not explicitly framed as failure, the concept implies a striving towards an ideal state.
●
Socialization: Boisen sees salvation as integration into a community of esteemed individuals and sin as isolation from that community. He connects this social psychological view with the Vaishnava emphasis on Krishna’s inherent social nature and the ultimate goal of joining Krishna’s society in Goloka Vrindavana. This suggests an area of convergence between the two perspectives, highlighting the importance of community in spiritual growth.
●
Spiritual Crisis as Growth: Boisen views spiritual crises, such as those experienced by individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia, as potential catalysts for profound spiritual growth, likening them to the experiences of figures like St. Paul and Jesus. While the sources do not specifically address the Vaishnava perspective on mental illness, the tradition emphasizes the purifying nature of suffering and trials on the spiritual path.
●
Resolution of Crisis: Boisen suggests that the resolution of a spiritual crisis can lead to sainthood or religious leadership when successful and to mental illness when unsuccessful. He proposes a framework for understanding the constructive and destructive ways individuals cope with these crises, leading to different outcomes. The Vaishnava tradition, with its emphasis on surrender and devotion to Krishna, likely offers a different approach to resolving crises, focusing on aligning oneself with the divine will and seeking guidance from spiritual authorities.
●
Application to Vaishnava Community: The speaker highlights the relevance of Boisen’s work for addressing the challenges faced by the ISKCON community, including the need for pastoral care, understanding different levels of commitment, and preventing spiritual stagnation. The speaker sees potential in applying Boisen’s insights to help devotees navigate personal struggles and foster a more inclusive community while upholding high spiritual standards.
It is important to note that the sources primarily focus on introducing Boisen’s ideas within a Vaishnava context. A comprehensive comparison would require further exploration of traditional Vaishnava texts and teachings.

How does Boisen’s work on the psychology of religious experience inform our understanding of the challenges and pathologies present within the ISKCON community?

This response examines Anton T. Boisen’s work on the psychology of religious experience and how it can enhance our understanding of the challenges and pathologies present in the ISKCON community based on the provided source.
Boisen and ISKCON
Boisen’s work is particularly relevant to ISKCON because he focuses on the psychological dynamics of groups with high ideals and the struggles individuals face when they feel they are failing to meet those standards. This resonates with the ISKCON experience, as the movement emphasizes strict adherence to a demanding set of principles, potentially leading to feelings of inadequacy among its members.
Boisen’s own background as a devout Christian who experienced a schizophrenic episode further illuminates this connection. He posits that spiritual crises, like his own, are common in individuals grappling with intense religious experiences, and the outcome can range from becoming a religious leader to becoming mentally ill.
Boisen’s Relevance to ISKCON
Boisen’s focus on social psychology is particularly applicable to ISKCON’s personalistic philosophy. He argues that an individual’s inner world reflects their social structure, emphasizing the human need for belonging and acceptance. This aligns with ISKCON’s emphasis on community and the importance of associating with devotees.
Within this framework, salvation becomes synonymous with acceptance into a community of esteemed individuals, while sin is equated with isolation from that community. This concept directly parallels the ISKCON ideal of attaining association with Krishna and His devotees while avoiding the material world.
Boisen as a Diagnostic Tool
Boisen provides a framework for understanding the challenges and pathologies that may arise in a community like ISKCON. His chart on “Personality Changes and Upheavals Arising out of a Sense of Personal Failure” offers a diagnostic tool for recognizing destructive responses to the pressures of adhering to high ideals. This chart could potentially assist ISKCON leaders and members in understanding and addressing issues within the community.
Pastoral Counseling and ISKCON
The source highlights the growing need for pastoral counseling within ISKCON. The movement’s emphasis on demanding standards and the challenges members face in meeting those standards necessitate a supportive and understanding approach. Boisen’s work on pastoral counseling, particularly his focus on ministering to individuals struggling with their faith and personal challenges, can provide valuable insights for ISKCON.
Similarities between Boisen and Prabhupada
Interestingly, Boisen, despite being a Christian, shares certain perspectives with ISKCON’s founder, Srila Prabhupada. For example, both advocate for total commitment and self-sacrifice in the service of God. This suggests that despite coming from different religious backgrounds, they recognized fundamental principles of spiritual life that transcend specific doctrines.
Potential for Dialogue
The source proposes that studying figures like Boisen could facilitate interfaith dialogue and help ISKCON members learn from other traditions without compromising their own philosophy. Boisen’s work may offer a bridge between ISKCON and other faiths, highlighting commonalities in the human search for meaning and spiritual fulfillment. This engagement could enrich ISKCON’s understanding of itself and its place in the wider religious landscape.
The source also suggests that Boisen himself might be considered a “lost devotee” who, despite his insights into spiritual life, never found the specific association that would have led him to Krishna consciousness. This highlights the universal nature of spiritual seeking and the potential for finding truth in unexpected places.
Overall, Boisen’s work provides a unique lens through which to examine the ISKCON experience. His focus on the psychology of religious experience, particularly in demanding communities with high ideals, can help illuminate the challenges, pathologies, and potential solutions within ISKCON.

What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of incorporating insights from Boisen’s work into the ISKCON movement, and how can we navigate these complexities while staying true to our core philosophy?

Incorporating Boisen’s Insights into ISKCON: Benefits, Drawbacks, and Navigation
Potential Benefits of Integrating Boisen’s Work:
●
Understanding Spiritual Crises: Boisen’s work offers valuable insights into the nature of spiritual crises, which can manifest as mental distress, and suggests that these experiences can be transformative periods of spiritual growth. This perspective could help ISKCON members understand and support individuals experiencing such challenges within the movement.
●
Pastoral Counseling and Support: Boisen pioneered clinical pastoral education, focusing on the care of those struggling with mental health issues. Integrating his approach could equip ISKCON leaders and members with the tools to provide effective pastoral counseling and support to individuals within the community, especially those grappling with personal failures or setbacks in their spiritual journey.
●
Addressing Sense of Personal Failure: A central theme in Boisen’s work is the concept of personal failure and its impact on spiritual development. His framework, emphasizing constructive ways of dealing with such feelings, could be invaluable in ISKCON, a movement with high standards that can lead to feelings of inadequacy among its members.
●
Broadening ISKCON’s Appeal and Inclusivity: Boisen’s focus on socialization within religious groups and the process of integrating individuals into a community aligns with ISKCON’s need to embrace a broader range of devotees with varying levels of commitment. His insights could help ISKCON become more inclusive and welcoming to those attracted to its teachings but struggling to fully embrace its practices.
●
Interfaith Dialogue and Understanding: Boisen’s exploration of universal spiritual laws transcends specific religious boundaries. His work could facilitate meaningful interfaith dialogue, allowing ISKCON to connect with other spiritual traditions while emphasizing shared values like commitment to God and self-sacrifice.
Potential Drawbacks and Complexities:
●
Compatibility with ISKCON’s Philosophy: While Boisen’s emphasis on total commitment to God resonates with ISKCON’s core values, certain aspects of his Christian theological framework may not fully align with Vaishnava philosophy. Integrating his insights requires careful consideration and adaptation to ensure consistency with ISKCON’s fundamental principles.
●
Risk of Dilution of Standards: Embracing a wider range of devotees and providing support for those struggling with spiritual practices necessitates a delicate balance. ISKCON must avoid compromising its core principles or lowering its standards of spiritual practice to accommodate a broader audience.
●
Potential for Misinterpretation or Misapplication: Boisen’s work, particularly his understanding of mental distress as spiritual crisis, could be misinterpreted or misapplied. ISKCON needs to establish clear guidelines and training to ensure his insights are used responsibly and ethically within the movement.
Navigating Complexities and Staying True to ISKCON Philosophy:
●
Selective Integration: ISKCON should carefully select and integrate aspects of Boisen’s work that align with its core philosophy and address specific needs within the movement. Prioritize the practical applications of his insights related to pastoral counseling, understanding spiritual crises, and addressing personal failure, while remaining discerning about theological concepts that might clash with Vaishnava teachings.
●
Emphasis on Scriptural Authority: When incorporating insights from Boisen, consistently refer back to the foundational scriptures of ISKCON, primarily the Bhagavad Gita and Srimad Bhagavatam. This grounding in scriptural authority ensures that Boisen’s concepts are understood and applied within the context of Vaishnava teachings.
●
Guidance from Senior Devotees: Seek guidance from senior and experienced devotees within ISKCON to ensure the proper adaptation and application of Boisen’s ideas. Their wisdom and understanding of Vaishnava philosophy can help navigate potential conflicts and ensure that any integration remains consistent with ISKCON’s core principles.
●
Open Dialogue and Discussion: Encourage open dialogue and discussion among ISKCON members about the potential benefits and challenges of incorporating Boisen’s insights. Transparent communication and thoughtful consideration of various perspectives can foster a balanced and informed approach.
By approaching the integration of Boisen’s work with care, discernment, and a commitment to scriptural authority, ISKCON can harness his valuable insights to address the needs of its community, enhance its outreach efforts, and navigate the complexities of modern spiritual life while staying true to its core philosophy.